Great to hear about the TPMS and lugs. Phew.
About value of the car - it will probably only be "worth" a few thousand by the time I get a new one. I've had my 2 cars for 9 and 8 years and I would have had my second car longer if hail hadn't destroyed it. Of course it's worth more than that to me since it still looks good and gets me to work and back reliably even if it's old, but you know how car "investments" go.
I could always sell the wheels separately as well and put the stocks back on if that made sense at the time. It probably depends if I sell it myself or not. If so, it could help having interesting wheels. This is so far down the road I won't bother thinking about it now though. Hopefully my xB doesn't get hit by tennis ball hail too, LOL.
I agree with your thoughts on OEM wheels, though it won't be what I'm doing. What does Mr. Clean have? I saw your pix but didn't think those were Scion wheels.
I wanted a dark color on my silver xB though and none of those are available. And of course the cost is much higher. Something that could be really cool would be to find some OEM wheels off some older car that caught my eye and fit and get them powdercoated a dark color.
These BMW wheels could be sweet but I don't think the bolt pattern fits.
BMW OEM Wheels and Tires - 16 inch
Powdercoat them gunmetal or something and put on a different cap. Holy cow that's the same tire size. I might have to email this person. Need to imagine how they'd look.